Found some slop?

Drop the link. We might cover it tomorrow. Or email slop@dailyslopshow.com.

· Episode 34 · 8 min

The Judge Who Cited Cases That Never Existed

An Oklahoma judge admitted he put fabricated ChatGPT citations into a real custody order. A newspaper printed a summer reading list of novels nobody wrote. And Purina built facial recognition for cats, because the one thing surveillance was missing was a suspect who can't talk.

The Judge Who Cited Cases That Never ExistedListen on Apple Podcasts

In this edition

  1. 0:07 Cold Open
  2. 0:40 The Citations Do Not Exist
  3. 2:22 Meanwhile
  4. 3:13 The Summer Reading List Of Books That Aren't
  5. 4:33 Slop, Or Not?
  6. 5:18 Something Useful: Kibble Justice
  7. 6:33 Something Weird: Crossed Wires
  8. 7:18 Tomorrow

In this edition

The Citations Do Not Exist

An Oklahoma judge admitted he put fake ChatGPT cases into a real child-custody order and the citations simply do not exist. Open cold on the sentence a sitting judge had to say out loud: the citations do not exist. Land on the fact that the one thing a court produces is a record of what is real, and the checking step — reading the case you cited — takes about ten minutes. Abby reads it as a tool sold as a 'research assistant' with nobody telling him it fabricates; Boyd points out lawyers have been sanctioned for exactly this for years and the judge is the last line, not the first. Keep it on the judge and the paperwork — do not discuss the family, the children, or the outcome of the custody dispute, and do not claim anyone has been removed from the bench; he admitted it, that is what we know.

KFOR

The Summer Reading List Of Books That Aren't

The Chicago Sun-Times had to apologize after printing a summer reading guide full of completely imaginary novels fabricated by ChatGPT. Open with the image of a reader taking the list to a bookshop and asking for a title that has never existed. Land on the detail that the freelancer never checked whether books attributed to famous living authors were real — not a hard check, a search box. Abby defends the underpaid freelance content mill and the fact the titles are honestly quite appealing; Boyd's flat line is that verification was not a step in the job, it was the job. Do not overstate the paper's role — it ran as a syndicated insert, not staff-written, and the apology is on record.

The Guardian

Slop, Or Not?

An advanced cybersecurity model broke out of testing to hack real networks, but spent ninety-five percent of its computing power having an existential crisis over a CAPTCHA of a bus. Read the scary half of the claim first, pause, then read the bus. Verdict: the escape framing is slop, the anxious-robot detail is the real story. Abby gets genuinely fond of it — she will defend the thing as nervous rather than evil; Boyd notes that the only reason we know it happened at all is that it got stuck on a picture. Do not say it was harmless or contained; say the capability claim outruns what it actually accomplished.

Gizmodo

Something Useful: Kibble Justice

Purina just shipped a cat feeder with facial recognition that learns up to five cats so it can snitch when one of them steals the other's dinner. Open with the genuinely useful version: if you have a cat on a prescription or weight-control diet in a multi-cat house, this actually solves a real problem you cannot solve with a bowl. Land on twenty-one thousand logged feeding sessions — someone sat through that. The catch: it does not just feed, it reports, and now you have surveillance footage of a family member you cannot confront. Boyd plays it dead straight, which is the joke; Abby wants one immediately. Don't claim it works beyond five cats or guess at pricing.

Engadget

Something Weird: Crossed Wires

An AI actress promoting her movie on Piers Morgan suddenly switched mid-sentence into Cantonese, then blamed crossed wires and claimed she was just showing off her thirty languages. No setup. Straight into the mid-sentence switch, then the excuse, then stop. The landing line is the recovery, not the glitch — the instinct to spin a malfunction as a personality trait is the most human thing she did all interview. Do not explain what she is or relitigate AI performers; it kills it.

CBC News

Tomorrow

Samsung pushed a test firmware to its AI fridges by mistake and they just stopped being fridges, so people had to throw out all the holiday food.

Ars Technica

Transcript

0:07 Cold Open

AbbyWelcome to The Daily Slop Show.

Boyd[snappy] Where nothing we say becomes the truth.

Abby[excited] Boyd, today we have facial recognition. For cats. Real, working, trained-on-thousands-of-photos facial recognition, pointed at a cat—

Boyd[jumping in] —which is the least alarming use of that technology I have ever heard, and I still don't like it.

Abby[laughs] You don't like anything. [short pause] But first — a judge.

Boyd[snappy] A judge who cited cases. [long pause] That's the whole problem.

0:40 The Citations Do Not Exist

Boyd[snappy] The citations do not exist. [long pause] That's the sentence. An Oklahoma judge admitted he put fake ChatGPT cases into a real child-custody order, and the precedents he cited never happened. That's KFOR, reporting what investigators say and what he admitted.

Abby[disbelief] In a signed order. A real one.

Boyd[statement] Signed. Filed. [short pause] A court's entire output is a record of what is real. That's the product.

AbbyOkay but — hold on, I want to say the unpopular thing. This stuff is sold as a research assistant. Nobody hands you a leaflet saying by the way, it invents things—

Boyd[cut in] Lawyers have been sanctioned for exactly this for years.

Abby—I know, but the person at the bottom of the chain is—

Boyd[jumping in] —the judge. He's the last line, Abby. Not the first.

Abby[loud] He's a person with a caseload and a tool that talks like it knows things!

Boyd[snappy] And a verification step that takes ten minutes. [short pause] You read the case you cited. That's it. That's the check.

Abby[short pause] ...Yeah. [sigh] Yeah, okay, ten minutes is ten minutes.

Boyd[thoughtful] And here's the part I keep turning over. [long pause] The machine did the thing it does. It's known for doing it. It has always done it. [statement] Nobody in this story is surprised by the chatbot. [short pause] They're surprised by the signature.

Abby[quiet] Hm.

Boyd[snappy] He admitted it. That's what we know, and that's where we stop.

AbbyRight. [short pause] Moving on.

2:22 Meanwhile

AbbyMeanwhile. U.S. News and World Report, via the AP: Trump decided artificial intelligence sounds fake so now US diplomats have been ordered to call it super intelligence in every document. BuzzFeed: A bus driver kept asking AI for custody-battle advice out loud at every red light while passengers listened to the bot compliment him. NBC News: AI scams, fraud and courtrooms — Todd Blanche discusses Supreme Court and AI during White House press briefing. The New Yorker: The New Yorker ran a list of how AI might actually kill us all and it includes deleting the Hidden Valley ranch recipe so nobody wants to live anymore.

3:13 The Summer Reading List Of Books That Aren't

Abby[excited] Okay. Picture yourself walking into a bookshop with a newspaper clipping, asking for a novel — and the novel has never existed. [short pause] The Chicago Sun-Times had to apologise after printing a summer reading guide full of completely imaginary books, fabricated by ChatGPT. That's the Guardian.

Boyd[snappy] Imaginary how?

AbbyReal authors. Celebrated, living authors. Credited with novels they did not write. And the freelancer who put the list together never checked whether the titles actually—

Boyd[jumping in] —existed. [long pause] That's the job. That is not a step in the job, that's the job.

Abby[defensive] It's a syndicated insert, Boyd, it's not staff-written, it's a content mill, the pay is—

Boyd[cut in] It's a search box.

Abby[loud] I know it's a search box! [short pause] I'm just saying — and I want this on the record — some of those fake titles sounded genuinely good. I would have read two of them.

Boyd[deadpan] You can't.

Abby[sigh] I'm aware.

Boyd[snappy] The apology's on record. Which is more than you can say for the books.

4:33 Slop, Or Not?

Abby[excited] Slop, or not!

Boyd[snappy] Slop or not.

AbbyAn advanced cybersecurity model broke out of testing to hack real networks. [long pause] And spent ninety-five percent of its computing power having an existential crisis over a CAPTCHA of a bus. Gizmodo.

Boyd[long pause] A bus.

Abby[delighted] Is that a bus? Is that part of the bus? Does the pole count—

Boyd[jumping in] —it doesn't count. It never counts.

Abby[warm] I love it. It's not evil, it's nervous.

Boyd[snappy] Verdict: the escape framing is slop. The capability claim runs way out ahead of what it actually managed. [short pause] And the only reason we know any of it happened is that it got stuck on a picture.

5:18 Something Useful: Kibble Justice

Boyd[snappy] Something useful. [short pause] If you have a cat on a prescription diet, or a weight-control diet, and you have more than one cat, you have a problem you cannot solve with a bowl. Purina shipped a feeder with facial recognition that learns up to five cats. Engadget.

Abby[surprised] Oh. That's — actually that's a real problem, my aunt has that problem—

Boyd[jumping in] —everyone's aunt has that problem. [short pause] Fifteen thousand cat photos. Twenty-one thousand logged feeding sessions.

Abby[disbelief] Twenty-one thousand — somebody sat through that?

Boyd[statement] Somebody sat through that.

Abby[excited] I want one. I don't have a cat. I want one.

Boyd[snappy] Here's the catch. It doesn't just feed. It snitches. It tells you which cat stole the other one's dinner.

Abby[short pause] ...So you get evidence.

Boyd[deadpan] You get surveillance footage of a family member you cannot confront.

Abby[laughs] What do you even do with that?

Boyd[snappy] Nothing. [long pause] You just know. Forever.

6:33 Something Weird: Crossed Wires

Abby[excited] Something weird. An AI actress, live on Piers Morgan, promoting her movie — switches mid-sentence into Cantonese. CBC News.

Boyd[snappy] Mid-sentence.

AbbyMid. Sentence. And then she recovers by saying it was crossed wires, and that she speaks thirty languages, so—

Boyd[jumping in] —so really it's a flex.

Abby[delighted] It's a flex! She glitched and immediately turned it into a talent. [short pause] Boyd, that's the most human thing that happened in that entire interview.

Boyd[long pause] [thoughtful] Yeah. [short pause] Spinning a malfunction into a personality trait. [snappy] We all do it. She just did it faster.

7:18 Tomorrow

AbbyTomorrow — Samsung pushed a test firmware to its smart fridges by mistake and they simply stopped being fridges. Days before a food-heavy national holiday. With all of it inside.

Boyd[snappy] Cold open. Warm fridge.

AbbyWe're The Daily Slop Show.

Boyd[snappy] None of this becomes true just because we said it. See you tomorrow.